By Stephen K. Gielda (sorry search engine seeding)
The web never forgets, however the big problem with this lies in the fact that everyone gets to record their voice on it. I suppose it was inevitable, my daughter running a web search on my name. She quickly stumbled upon some of the pages and posts made by a few of the more unstable individuals who’s path I crossed.
I hear my mother even fell for some forgeries pretending to be me. Anyway, such is life in my chosen field. I seem to have a small (very small) celebrity status in certain circles, and as with any (very small) celebrity I have my detractors as well, The yang must balance the ying, I guess. Unfortunately, the yang can be very loud.
A little history may be required. Back in 1998 through 2001 Cotse ran a free web interface that posted directly through the then replay, now dizum, mail2news gateway. It wasn’t anonymous, but it was private. In addition we provided some cypherpunk resources.
In order to be responsible and address any real abuse that happened, we included our contact information in the headers of messages posted through our interface, so as to handle our own abuse issues so they would not be a load on alex (who ran replay/dizum in the NL). This was my introduction into the deep bowels of a thing called Usenet.
Usenet is a discussion forum. Many today think of it as Google Groups, because Google bought the Deja News archives, but Usenet is it’s own entity. Google is merely displaying an archive, making it searchable, and providing a NNTP web interface, allowing the masses to post through pretty web forms instead of a usenet client. Kind of like what we did on a much smaller scale (ours, not theirs).
Usenet is full of sociopaths. Forum kings and queens. If you have ever seen a craigslist rants and raves forum for any city, you know how it gets when you add a little anonymity. People are vulgar, scathing, insipid, beasts when they can hide. So it is inevitable that egos will clash and insults fly.
The name of the game is to seriously muddy your opponents name and if possible win your argument by account term. It includes forgeries and then complaining about the forgeries as if their opponent posted them. The game is still being played across many forums on the Internet today. It was one of the original reasons I began Cotse (Cotse’s privacy side began as a free web to news interface)
People were and are still losing their Internet access based upon exaggerated lies from someone they crossed online who knows how to play the game. They are also ending up with their name returning 72,000+ hits due to some lunatic. It still happens. If the claims sound real, the forged headers look real, the forged “evidence” looks real enough…
So I created a web to news poster, to add a shield between them and their ISP and their identity. Naturally this was going to place me (Stephen K. Gielda (more search engine seeding)) at odds with some of the most unstable of individuals when they had no one to attack personally but me.
In addition, that abuse info in the headers along with replay info also caused another problem. It made some people assume that everything that came out of the mixmaster and cypherpunk remailers came from us. There was no convincing them this was not the case. It was also easily to forge, (anyone could post directly to replay mail2new just like my form did).
When some did did not get their way they came after me personally and my service. There were many, but there were a few that really brought that little bit extra to the party. One example was an individual who contacted me demanding that I terminate the account of a user of ours who called him a liar.
He claimed that this was criminal libel and I was aiding and abetting a known criminal if I did not act and remove the account (there were no accounts at this stage). That his notice was enough to prove that I was complicit if I did not remove the account. He had entire volumes full of why it was my responsibility to silence my user. I investigated, our user was not abusing our service in any way, it was a standard forum flamefest with both posters arguing heatedly.
So I (Stephen K. Gielda) informed him that we were not a court of law and could not determine if him being called a liar was libel and that he would need to file suit against our user if he believed it to be. That once we were notified of a subpoena for information, we would comply. Well, he went off the deep end.
The emails became more demanding, more threatening, more vulgarity laced. He was going to make sure the entire Internet knew how evil a person I was if I did not terminate this account. He followed me wherever I went, attacking everything I posted anywhere. He started forging me and my service.
Now here is where I made a mistake, being new to all this, I got fed up with him and his threats and said “Yes, I think it is perfectly ok that he called you a liar, I can certainly think of far more apt things to call you. Now ___ off with all the threats and sue us if you have a case. We are accepting no more email from you.” And I blocked his mail.
He really went ballistic. He started posting web pages dedicated to me. He called me every name in the book. He appeared in other forums and posted pretending to be different people making allegations about me. He posted that my business was a scam in may different web forums. He started small, but rapidly moved to more serious allegations. He seeded search engines to make good on his promise that all would know. He even found my address and called my local police and my neighbors. I even received a visit from the FBI.
This continued for years. Sometimes he’d taper off for a little, then come back form a different angle. I finally had enough and shut down the web2new interface in favor of just mixmaster (because they can’t be traced back to us).
He eventually peaked in a flurry of anonymous posts asking for a contract killing for me (Stephen K. Gielda) (see the links here). In fact one of those was printed out and stuck under my windshield wiper by someone who must have seen me and opted for the flyer instead. Funny how he thought he should be able to post that all against me and keep his account, but I need to silence anyone using our web form for calling him a liar.
Yet the damage he did to my name (Stephen K. Gielda), sorry, I know it’s annoying) still remains, some of his pages return high in searches because of his search engine seeding. Some of his forgeries do as well. I never paid it much accord, because I figured anyone reading it all would see it was the work of someone unstable and easily see through it, but every once in a while I find myself explaining. Something out of context appears in a search.
Unfortunately, the screams of the insane echo for quite some time on the Internet. Perhaps this post will appear equally high in the search now and I won’t have to explain so many times. . I think he was committed somewhere.
Thanks,
Stephen K. Gielda